At a Glance

Discipline

  • Physics

Instructional Level

  • College & CEGEP

Course

  • NYC Waves, Light, and Modern Physics

Tasks in Workflow

Social Plane(s)

  • Group
  • Whole Class

Type of Tasks

  • Solving problems
  • Reviewing & assessing peers
  • Writing

Technical Details

Useful Technologies

  • Whiteboards

Time

Single class period (< 90 mins)

Purpose

  • Application & practice

Overview

In this activity, students, working in groups, are asked to answer a series of problems on the wave theory of light and double-slit interference by starting from a drawing instead of a pre-memorised formula. After students have achieved a conceptual understanding of the theory by using drawings, they can start using formulae to solve increasingly harder problems.

Students solve problems 0, 1 and 2 (see attached material for examples) using the drawing of concentric circles.  

Problem2 is quite hard, and most groups are not actually expected to reach a solution; if no ...

Read More +

In this activity, students, working in groups, are asked to answer a series of problems on the wave theory of light and double-slit interference by starting from a drawing instead of a pre-memorised formula. After students have achieved a conceptual understanding of the theory by using drawings, they can start using formulae to solve increasingly harder problems.

Students solve problems 0, 1 and 2 (see attached material for examples) using the drawing of concentric circles.  

Problem2 is quite hard, and most groups are not actually expected to reach a solution; if no group reaches a solution in around 25 minutes, the instructor will further explain the problem by presenting the appropriate picture. After the problem and picture are understood, the instructor presents to the students a solution with formulae.

The instructor then describes problem3  which, because of the distances involved, cannot be solved by drawing a picture. If there is still time, students can then begin to work on problem4; if not, they are expected to work on this at home and it will be discussed at the beginning of the following class.

Peer instruction between groups is encouraged - students are told to ask each other for advice and explanations instead of asking the teacher. Of course, the instructor also provides guidance and clarifies concepts.

Read Less -

Instructional Objectives

The purpose of this activity is for students to grasp the concept behind the formulae by first answering a problem using a drawing. This allows them to develop a qualitative, image-based solution in mind instead of simply applying a series of memorised, “correct” formulae.

Workflow & Materials

Activity Workflow

Forget the Math! Draw pictures to learn abstract concepts in the wave theory of light

Download

Drawing Pictures As The Problem Solving Approach in a Physics Course

Teacher Instructions

Download

Contributor's Notes

Oscar Hernández
Oscar Hernández

Marianopolis College, Montreal, QC, McGill University, Montreal, QC

Benefits

  • This activity allows students to develop a picture and conceptual understanding of the formulae and the elements that are at play; they can consider the reason for which the formulae exists;
  • This enables students to solve a broader range of conceptually similar problems, instead of simply knowing how to apply a formula to one set of problem statements.

Challenges

  • Approaching a problem this way takes more time than through a traditional teaching mode;
  • There is resistance both on part of students, who may feel the instructor is not really teaching them, and other colleagues unfamiliar with the approach.

Tips

  • This activity is not done at the beginning of the term nor is it the first physics class for the students, therefore most are already familiar with the instructor’s use of this teaching style, which limits resistance.
  • The role of the teacher is to support and accompany the students and mitigate frustration in the concept learning stage, rather than provide correct answers to the problems.

Applied Strategies

  1. 1
    Problem-Based Learning
  2. 2
    Peer Instruction / Think-pair-share

Feedback

Leave a comment! Activities get better when we receive feedback and understand how they might be adapted and reused. Please let us know what you think after using this Activity, or if you have questions about how it might be used differently.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *