Force Identification

By Jeremie Choquette , Dawson College

Force Identification

At a Glance

Discipline

  • Physics
  • STEM

Instructional Level

  • College & CEGEP

Tasks in Workflow

Social Plane(s)

  • Individual
  • Group
  • Whole Class

Type of Tasks

  • Reading
  • Writing
  • Discussing
  • Solving problems

Technical Details

Class size

  • Small (20-49)

Time

  • Brief segment of class period (< 20 mins)

Instructional Purpose

  • Exploration & inquiry
  • Application & knowledge building

Overview

In this activity, students will learn to create a free body diagrams from more complex images. This is designed as a precursor to the interacting objects activity, designed to teach students to simplify their diagrams themselves rather than have the instructor do so for them.

Prior to class, students complete a reading assignment on types of forces and identifying forces. They then complete a reflective writing, summarizing the chapter and explaining the questions and problems they encountered during the reading.

Once in class, the instructor breaks the students into groups of 3-4. In their groups, students are tasked with finding an image of a stationary object online and sketching it, labeling all the forces acting on the object and drawing them as vectors. The groups then simplify their sketch to basic shapes (boxes, circles, etc.) and again label the forces. They then simplify their sketch further to a single dot with force vectors originating from it – this is introduced as a free body diagram. During this time, the instructor circulates about the room, providing assistance.

When students have completed their free body diagrams, the instructor chooses one of the examples to complete as an example in front of the class, demonstrating an efficient way of reducing the sketch to a simpler one then to a free body diagram.

This process is repeated for a moving object, then for two objects interacting (requiring two free body diagrams). This can be used to (briefly) hint at the upcoming concepts behind Newton’s second law (for the moving object) and Newton’s third law (for the interacting objects).

Instructional Objectives

  • Students learn to identify forces and simplify force diagrams, ending with a free body diagram.

Workflow & Materials

Workflow

Activity Workflow

View on CourseFlow

Contributor's Notes

Benefits
Challenges
Tips
Benefits
  • This is a very simple activity without any calculations or technology required. This was initially designed to fill the time after a test (on kinematics), giving students a more relaxed activity.
  • Students tend to enjoy this activity, and it gets them thinking about forces in their everyday lives.
Challenges
  • Left to their own devices, students will often have trouble simplifying their diagrams or identifying the forces.
  • It’s very important that the instructor move from group to group to provide assistance.
Tips
  • The Momentum Photoproject and Interacting Objects activities have a similar component in which students identify forces, however students often have difficulty simplifying their diagrams. This activity gives students practice doing this themselves, rather than having the instructor simplify the diagrams for them.
  • Some textbooks tell students to find forces by placing one at each point of contact. However in most cases this can be simplified – for example a table with four legs should have simply one normal force from the floor. This is the reason for the intermediate step, in which the table might be represented by a box, and it’s therefore important not to skip this step.

Applied Strategies

Feedback

Leave a comment! Activities get better when we receive feedback and understand how they might be adapted and reused. Please let us know what you think after using this Activity, or if you have questions about how it might be used differently.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *