At a Glance

Discipline

  • Biology

Instructional Level

  • University

Tasks in Workflow

Social Plane(s)

  • Individual
  • Group
  • Whole Class

Type of Tasks

  • Collecting & seeking information
  • Discussing
  • Writing

Technical Details

Useful Technologies

  • Projector (optional)

Class size

  • Small (20-49)

Time

Multiple class periods (2-3 classes)

Overview

In this activity, students debate whether mindfulness can effectively heal the brain after a traumatic experience to minimize negative mental health symptoms.

During Class 1, 3-5 students (depending on class size) are chosen as judges for the debate while the rest of the class is divided into two teams. The instructor then plays Video Clips 1, 2, and 3 to introduce students to the idea of stress, biological trauma, and what a traumatized person experiences. The instructor then poses the question: "can mindfulness therapy actually reverse physiological effects of trauma in the brain?" Students go home and research the topic to understand brain plasticity ...

Read More +

In this activity, students debate whether mindfulness can effectively heal the brain after a traumatic experience to minimize negative mental health symptoms.

During Class 1, 3-5 students (depending on class size) are chosen as judges for the debate while the rest of the class is divided into two teams. The instructor then plays Video Clips 1, 2, and 3 to introduce students to the idea of stress, biological trauma, and what a traumatized person experiences. The instructor then poses the question: "can mindfulness therapy actually reverse physiological effects of trauma in the brain?" Students go home and research the topic to understand brain plasticity and trauma, and find evidence for their team's viewpoint (Team 1 for, Team 2, against).

During Class 2, students get into their assigned team, and build their case with the evidence they have found. Each team chooses people to debate (2-3 rounds of debate/rebuttal, depending on class size and length, lasting 5 minutes each).

Judges make decision on who won the debate, and instructor debriefs the class to address any misconceptions about the brain and to answer student questions. Instructor then shows Video Clip 4 and 5, and explains that the answer is probably a mix of both sides: mindfulness therapy may not be able to completely erase the physiological affects of trauma on the brain, but it can help to reduce to psychological effects experienced, allowing trauma survivors to be more grounded in the present.

Read Less -

Instructional Objectives

Students exercise critical thinking skills (researching for evidence), and learn to evaluate facts (debate) and create (rebuttle) counter-arguments. Ultimately, students should gain a deeper understanding of neuroplasticity through the subject lens of trauma.

Workflow & Materials

Activity Workflow

Ctrl + Alt + Del: PTSD and Neuroplasticity

Download

Debate Instructions & Answers

Teacher instructions

Download

Example articles

Article

Download

Contributor's Notes

Daniel Goldsmith
Daniel Goldsmith

Dawson College, Montreal, QC

Benefits

Debates are an engaging way of teaching material, and allowing students to evaluate facts for themselves. It involves individual and group work, which ensures that students practice working alone and with peers.

Challenges

Some students may not want to participate in the debate in terms of presenting.

Tips

Students that do not want to debate can act as judges. That way, they still play an active role in the debate, but do not have to present within the debate itself.

Applied Strategies

  1. 1
    Debates

Feedback

Leave a comment! Activities get better when we receive feedback and understand how they might be adapted and reused. Please let us know what you think after using this Activity, or if you have questions about how it might be used differently.

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *